Cardgame Coalition's Custom Card Challenge!

I couldn't actually fit the flavour text I wanted, but it should obviously say Winter is coming. because obviously. And, yeah, lateral reference to Fimbulvetr via mechanical Opposition riff.

And now, let's vote!

So we have a tie.

How can we solve this?

They speak in PM to discuss a 2-card challenge?

Sounds like a nice idea.

So, .Rai and Capricorn shall discuss and post a 2-week, 2-card challenge :3

For the record had I not passed out last night before I could have voted, I would have voted for Rai's card. idk if it's fair to retroactively consider that, though.

Ashiok wrote:For the record had I not passed out last night before I could have voted, I would have voted for Rai's card. idk if it's fair to retroactively consider that, though.

Oh, so you didn't vote?

I think this is the only way we can break the tie without making another pool. What do you guys think?

I don't mind if .Rai gets the winning spot so yeah have it count Ashiok's vote

In celebration of FTV:Annihilation.

Pretty Straight Foward...but hey...

Simic Evolution Mist 3UUUGG
Sorcery 

Exile all creatures. For each creature exiled this way, that creatures controller searches his or her Library for a creature card with CMC 1+ the creature exiled this way.

With this we begin the search for the ultimate life form. 

I will set up Voting now.

Edit-So uh, Rod said I could edit the poll, but I'm not seeing anyway to do that here.

Actually, I think I forgot to mention (or not), but this'll be a 2 week pool because the challenge was posted a bit late.

Ah, alright. My mistake

So, voting should be today then?

Sorry for the absence, I'll postpone this another day. We'll vote tomorrow ^^

Gonna give a few more hours for more people to submit their cards.

Time for the pool~

I'll have to vote for Chaotic Karma. Such an interesting card.

Chaotic Karma seems like way too much of a punishing card, since the player behind on life is generally the one behind in the game already. It's weird in that it also wins the game by prolonging it, which doesn't make a lot of sense. Why are you giving life to the person who now just loses? It's just weird in terms of flavour.

Genocidal Fruition is a good card, and suits the golgari colour pair nicely but it's not really "interesting".

Macroseism is, again, a good card, but it's just Armageddon fused with Black's life drain without the drain part.

Simic Evolution Mist is overcosted for constructed (but all of these cards are) but I imagine that it's by far the most fun to be casting. Birthing Pod is definitely one of the more interesting cards to be activating but a mass pod for each player seems absolutely insane to try and resolve, while being the only card submitted that isn't in some way a punishing card for the caster or the opponent.

imo, it's a landslide victory for Simic Evolution Mist.

Thanks Chris  

I like the giving a thought on each card thing, think I'll do that next time too.

And Capricorn wins again, now bring us the next challenge :3

Got it quite ready:
2 Weeks Challenge

You must do a Total of 3 Cards for this Challenge.
The 3 Cards must tell a Story (Depicting an Initial Situation, a Conflict and an Ending of sorts), about any character or plane. It can be about any character even ones you made up. Cards not Necesarily have to be Creatures and doesn't have to work with each other, but the Flavor must fit the situation it depicts.

Well that's a lot of things to think

So Good luck, have fun!!!

Huh, interesting. This should be fun